Landlords make common mistakes that can have severe financial and legal repercussions.
The top legal mistakes that Landlords make often can be attributed to a lack of knowledge of the laws that regulate the rental property sector in South Africa, particularly the Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999.
The Rental Housing Act aims, among other objectives, to establish the government’s role in regulating rental housing, ensuring the proper functioning of the rental market and balancing the interests of both parties while preventing unfair practices and arbitrary evictions.
Landlords in South Africa face distinct challenges as the Rental Housing Act has undergone prolonged amendments, requiring them to consider pre- and post-amendment provisions.
A comprehensive understanding of the Act is crucial for safeguarding their interests and ensuring effective property management.
This article explores common legal mistakes Landlords make and offers practical solutions to mitigate these risks.
One of the most common legal mistakes Landlords make is failing to provide a Written Lease Agreement. This oversight can lead to numerous challenges.
Without a written lease, it becomes difficult to prove the terms of the agreement, including the rental amount, late payment penalties, and each party’s rights and responsibilities.
The absence of a written lease creates ambiguity, resulting in misunderstandings and disputes that can be challenging to resolve due to the inability to prove the initial terms.
While the current Rental Housing Act does not mandate Written Lease Agreements, and verbal lease agreements remain legally valid, the incoming Rental Housing Amendment Act will. Section 5(1) specifically stipulates that Landlords must reduce the lease agreement to writing.
Thus, having a written lease agreement is highly recommended as good practice. Providing a written lease agreement protects both the Landlord and the tenant by clarifying the terms of the agreement.
Section 5(6) of the Amendment Rental Housing Act further details the particulars that should be added to a lease agreement. Some of the specifications include:
– identifying the Landlord and tenant, including their addresses and contact information.
– the rental property and the tenant’s rights to use and enjoy the space should be clearly defined.
– the rental amount, along with any other applicable fees, the frequency of payment and the deposit, if any, should also be included in the lease agreement.
Additionally, the lease should state its duration, indicating whether it is for a fixed term or a periodic arrangement, and specify the notice period required for termination. Including a renewal clause can also be beneficial, as it outlines the tenant’s opportunity to renew the lease and the conditions that must be met for this renewal to occur.
Landlords frequently make a common legal mistake when handling security deposits. While requiring a deposit is legitimate and recognised by the Rental Housing Act, the main issue arises in the management of that deposit. Landlords neglect to place the deposit in an interest-bearing account as required by law.
Furthermore, some Landlords may withhold a portion or even the entire deposit, mistakenly believing it can be used for damages-related repairs. However, the amount withheld often does not accurately reflect the actual damage or loss, if there is any. This legal oversight can lead to significant consequences for Landlords.
The Rental Housing Act, both the current version and the incoming Amendment Act, requires that security deposits be placed in an interest-bearing account. This requirement is stipulated in section 5(3)(d) of the current Act and reiterated in section 4B(b) of the Amendment Act.
At the end of the lease, section 5(3)(g)(i) required that if no amounts are owed to the Landlord, they refund the deposit and the accumulated interest to the tenant without deductions within 7 days following the lease’s expiration.
Deductions may be made for any amounts owed or legitimate costs related to damage repairs incurred during the lease period. In these instances, the payment to the tenant must be issued within 14 days.
Landlords are also required to provide written records of any deductions made. If a tenant does not attend the joint exit inspection, the deposit may be refunded to them within 21 days.
Section 16(Ab) of the Amendment to the Rental Housing Act will make it illegal for Landlords to neglect these requirements.
Consequently, Landlords must deposit all security deposits into an interest-bearing account and maintain thorough records of any deductions made at the end of the rental period.
Landlords often delay responding to repair requests from their tenants, frequently postponing them until the last minute or neglecting them altogether. This behaviour can also occur when tenants express concerns, leading to frustration and disputes.
Such actions may have legal consequences, as they violate the Rental Housing Act. When these issues are not addressed, tenants have options for recourse against Landlords.
Possible actions include demanding specific performance, seeking cancellation of the lease in extreme cases, claiming damages, and requesting reimbursement for repair costs from the Landlord.
Landlords are responsible for maintaining the property in a condition reasonably suitable for its intended use, an obligation recognised in the current Act and in section 4B(11) of the Amendment Act.
Maintenance, as defined in the Amendment Act, ensures the residence remains habitable. It includes necessary repairs, replacing defective items, and addressing issues that arise over time due to normal wear and tear.
By conducting and documenting inspections as required by the Act, Landlords can monitor maintenance issues as they arise and address them promptly. Additionally, Landlords can maintain a record of these repairs to protect themselves from false claims.
Landlords often make a common legal mistake by entering a tenant’s property without prior notice. This unannounced intrusion disregards the tenant’s right to privacy and undermines their sense of security.
Section 4(d) of the Rental Housing Act defines a tenant’s right to privacy and provides that Landlords should avoid infringing upon this fundamental right without a legitimate legal reason and should always provide reasonable notice to the tenant.
The Act does not specify a fixed notice period for property inspections or repairs, but a notice period of 24 to 48 hours is generally considered reasonable practice.
The Landlord must always seek the tenant’s consent before entering the property, except in emergencies, such as a fire or burst pipes, where immediate access is necessary.
If the Landlord fails to provide reasonable notice or seeks entry without consent in non-emergency circumstances, it could be considered harassment.
Landlords sometimes mistakenly attempt illegal evictions. The Prevention of Illegal Evictions from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act (PIE) outlines the procedural and substantive requirements to obtain a court eviction order.
Failure to follow these steps results in unlawful evictions and potential legal consequences for the Landlord.
A key requirement is that the court, through the sheriff, must serve a written notice of the eviction proceedings to the tenant and the local municipality at least 14 days before the hearing.
Under Section 4 of the PIE Act, a landowner seeking eviction must prove:
Even if the lease has been lawfully terminated, the court may still refuse to grant an eviction order if it determines that the eviction would not be just and equitable. Moreover, eviction orders are not automatically granted simply because the lease is terminated.
Additionally, the sheriff must carry out the eviction, not the Landlord. Due to the sensitive nature of this procedure, Landlords are strongly advised to consult an attorney before beginning eviction proceedings to ensure the process is conducted effectively and appropriately.
Landlords can unintentionally violate anti-discrimination laws during tenant screening by considering protected characteristics such as race, gender, sexual orientation, or disability. Section 4(1) of the Rental Housing Act makes general provisions against unfair discrimination of tenants on grounds related to inter alia, race, gender, sex, pregnancy, marital status, age, disability, religion and belief.
The Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act (PEPUDA) prohibits discrimination in housing, and additional protections under the Rental Housing Act prevent Landlords from imposing unfair conditions based on race, gender, marital status, or family responsibility.
However, not all forms of discrimination are illegal. Landlords may legally refuse tenants based on financial factors, such as credit history, affordability, or rental payment reliability.
Landlords should implement consistent, objective criteria when evaluating all potential tenants to avoid violating anti-discrimination laws and ensure fairness.
To create fair and compliant screening criteria, Landlords should:
1) Focus on Objective Factors: Assess tenant ability through:
– Credit History: Evaluate financial responsibility.
– Rental History: Check reliability and care for property.
– Income Verification: Confirm that income meets the rent-to-income ratio.
– Background Checks: Assess criminal history without disqualifying for minor offences.
2) Avoid Discriminatory Criteria: Do not consider protected characteristics like race, gender, or religion.
3) Set Clear Standards: Document and apply criteria consistently to all applicants.
Following these steps promotes a fair and inclusive tenant screening process.
Landlords often make a legal mistake by neglecting their tax obligations. Some common instances of this oversight include the following:
1. Failing to Declare Rental Income: Rental income is taxable under the Income Tax Act, as it falls within the definition of gross income in section 1.
Landlords must report all rental income from both residential and commercial properties. Not declaring it can lead to severe penalties, including SARS penalties, interest, and backdated taxes.
2. Overlooking Deductions: The Income Tax Act makes provisions for deductions; certain amounts are thus exempt from gross income for tax purposes. Section 11(a) deals explicitly with general deduction.
While Landlords can deduct expenditures and losses actually incurred in the production of income, such as maintenance costs, they often miss out on these opportunities.
3. Incorrectly Classifying Expenses: Accurate expense classification is crucial. To avoid penalties, Landlords must ensure that capital improvements are treated correctly and not confused with regular operational expenses.
4. Not Keeping Accurate Records: It is essential to maintain detailed records of income and expenses. Justifying deductions becomes difficult without proper documentation, which could result in higher taxes.
Failure to comply with tax obligations can lead to severe consequences, including financial penalties for undeclared income or improper deductions.
Leases can end in various ways, but it is essential to adhere to the terms of the agreement and the law. Tenants must receive adequate notice before the termination unless it occurs at the end of the lease period.
If termination occurs before the lease ends, proper notice must be given to the tenant. In the case of a fixed-term lease, the notice period may be specified in the lease agreement; the contract’s terms will dictate the nature of the notice and how it should be implemented.
If the lease agreement does not specify a notice period, the applicable notice period depends on the type of lease. The Consumer Protection Act (CPA) requires 20 business days’ notice for fixed-term leases exceeding six months.
For periodic leases, common law generally requires one calendar month’s notice.
Landlords can avoid this common pitfall by providing tenants with the appropriate notice outlined by law or the lease agreement.
Understanding and avoiding common legal mistakes is essential for Landlords. This helps ensure compliance and effective management of rental properties.
Failing to provide a written lease agreement, mishandling deposits, violating tenant privacy, or not following eviction procedures and tax obligations can lead to serious consequences.
By staying informed, Landlords can protect their investments and maintain positive relationships with tenants, creating a lawful and pleasant rental experience.
Landlords can consult with an attorney to help ensure compliance with relevant laws and prevent potential issues. This approach minimises risks and enhances property management success.
By doing so, Landlords can confidently navigate rental challenges while safeguarding their legal and financial interests.
If you’re unsure about your legal obligations as a Landlord or need assistance with property-related matters, contact Martin Vermaak Attorneys for expert advice.
© 2025 Martin Vermaak Attorneys. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use Privacy Policy
